I found this review I wrote in college for the Demon-Haunted World by Carl Sagan. Apparently I wasn't too fond of the book:
The Demon-Haunted World is a very intelligent book that demands respect in
its thoroughness and longevity. Carl Sagan identifies today’s misconceptions
and systematically picks them apart piece by piece. That being said, I believe
The Demon-Haunted World to be repetitive and somewhat insulting in its
processes.
The repetitiveness of
Sagan’s book is most likely due to its format and origin. The Demon-Haunted
World is a collection of essays, and being so does not feel uniform or smooth
in its transitions. When I say that the book does not feel uniform, I mean each
chapter doesn’t assume that you’ve read the chapter before it. There is a
knowledge build up with most books that you read, but each chapter in The
Demon-Haunted World has its own introduction and explanation of concepts which
were explained in the previous chapter and the chapter before that. This leads
to a sort of irritation and reluctance to keep reading.
In one of the opening
chapters, Sagan points out that one of the top box office movies during the
time that he was writing his book was Dumb and Dumber. He also tells the reader
that a very popular television show of this time is Beavis and Butthead. Sagan
presents both of these pieces of information and alludes to a decline in 21
st
century human intelligence. This makes Sagan seem like a bitter old man
pointing out the flaws with the whippersnappers of the current generation while
he reminisces upon the golden age of his hay day.
To be
specific Sagan states, “The dumbing down of America is most evident in the slow
decay of substantive content in the enormously influential media, the 30-second
sound bites (now down to 10-seconds or less), lowest common denominator
programming, credulous presentations on pseudoscience and superstition, but
especially a kind of celebration of ignorance.” What Sagan sees as a
celebration of ignorance, I see as an escape from multitasking mania. In the
go-go-go world that we live in today, where it’s nearly impossible to
accomplish everything that we need to without multitasking all of the time,
it’s nice to turn your brain off for an hour or two to watch some mindless
entertainment.
The Demon-Haunted World is
a fantastic book with valuable processes, quotes, and cautions, however I do
not agree with all of Mr. Sagan's views. I would consider it
somewhat dangerous to think of everyone of Sagan’s notions as gospel. Sagan
says it best himself, “if we can’t think for ourselves, if we’re unwilling to
question authority, then we’re just putty in the hands of those in power.”